Navigation and service

9. Oxidative stress

In the context of possible health-relevant effects of electromagnetic fields, the concept of oxidative stress is often discussed. Oxidative stress is an imbalance in cells or tissues in which more reactive molecules or atoms are present than can be broken down by cellular processes, thereby resulting in the chemical modification of biomolecules that are essential for cell function. Oxidative stress can result from a reduction in the formation of reducing compounds and enzymes in the cell and/or increased formation of reactive chemical species, mostly reactive oxygen species (ROS) or reactive nitrogen species (RNS).

In principle, it is important to distinguish between the concepts of oxidative stress, oxidative damage, and oxidative challenge. Oxidative challenge also leads to an increase in reactive chemical species. However, this can be compensated for by cellular processes so that no chemical changes occur in important biomolecules. Oxidative challenges can even be useful for the cell because it can then better adapt to further and future stress factors. When cells are subjected to oxidative stress, essential biomolecules are chemically modified by reactive species. However, the cell has repair mechanisms that can reverse these modifications.

Oxidative damage occurs when there is an irreversible modification of biomolecules (e.g. genetic material in the form of DNA, proteins, and carbohydrates). This can lead to the change, impairment, or loss of function of the cell or tissue. Mutations initiated by oxidation processes (alteration of DNA) also belong to this category insofar as these mutations are not reversed. Permanently altered metabolism and permanently increased formation of reactive species triggered by previous oxidative processes also count as oxidative damage.

Reactive oxygen or nitrogen species or other reactive chemical species naturally occur as part of signalling processes and immune reactions. It is only the uncontrolled, non-regulable, and increased occurrence of such compounds that leads to oxidative stress or oxidative damage.

In connection with electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields, it has been reported that these compounds lead to an increased formation of oxidising chemical species in the cell. In addition, the triggering of oxidative stress is postulated as a possible mechanism of action of electromagnetic fields. Oxidative stress can, in turn, lead to the development of cancer and neurodegenerative diseases or promote the formation and progression of these diseases. The negative effects of electromagnetic fields on human fertility have also been connected with the triggering of oxidative stress.

However, the existing studies are quite heterogeneous, both in terms of the presence or absence of the aforementioned effects and in their overall quality.

As part of a systematic review, the study situation and the quality of research on oxidative stress and electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields are summarised and assessed. If further research is needed as a result of the systematic review, further studies will be initiated.

Research projects

9.1. Evaluative literature study on the influence of electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields on oxidative processes in humans and in animal and laboratory studiesShow / Hide

Project management: Fraunhofer ITEM, Hannover
Start: 1 September 2019
End: 30 November 2020

Background

The triggering of oxidative stress is postulated as a mechanism how non-ionising electromagnetic fields could exert negative effects on the function of cells (and moreover on organs or the whole body). Oxidative stress is the increased formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) that can no longer be compensated for by cellular processes. ROS are very reactive and react with important biomolecules such as proteins and nucleic acids. The existing scientific literature on this topic is inconsistent and often shows qualitative deficiencies in its implementation. It is thus difficult to make clear statements on the relevance of oxidative stress from a radiation protection perspective.

Objectives

In order to analyse and evaluate the ambiguous study situation, a systematic review will be conducted. The aim is to provide a sound assessment of the influence of electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields on oxidative stress as well as a qualitative evaluation of the published studies. If necessary, possible future research needs are to be derived from the results of the systematic review.

Implementation

Prior to the actual work on the systematic review, a study protocol will be prepared and published on the Prospero-Webseite. This protocol will contain the exact details of how the systematic review was conducted (i.e. information on the search strategy and the assessment of study quality, among other things).

The DistillerSR software for systematic reviews will be used to analyse and evaluate the data from the literature collected. The manual published by the Office of Health Assessment and Translation (OHAT) will be used to assess the studies.

The search, selection, and processing of the literature will be carried out according to the guidelines of the Centre for Reviews and Dissemination.

The systematic review will be is guided by the PECO questions (Population, Exposure, Comparators and Outcome). Together with the PRISMA guidelines, these are decisive for the development of the protocol and the review. Criteria for the evaluation of the literature include a blinded experimental design, quality of exposure to electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields and the inclusion of controls. When assessing the quality of the studies, the way in which oxidative stress was measured also plays a decisive role. The literature will be assessed and the data will be extracted independently by two reviewers.

At the end of the systematic review, the literature will be assessed with regard to the quality of the studies and their informative value on the relationship between oxidative stress and electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields.

Site information and functions

© Bundesamt für Strahlenschutz