- Are the fields produced by high-voltage power lines hazardous for residents?
Many people are worried about potential health effects of
electric and magnetic fields in the vicinity of high-voltage power lines.
Observing
the limit values ensures protection against adverse health effects caused by
low-frequency electric and magnetic fields according to the present state of scientific
knowledge. Due to existing scientific uncertainties, however, (see “Biological
and Health Effects of Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields”)
the exposure to low-frequency magnetic fields, such as those produced by
high-voltage power lines, should as a precaution be kept as low as possible –
even if they are well below the limit values. Nevertheless, the fact that only
in very rare cases do high-voltage power lines represent the essential part of
the fields people are exposed to in every day life must be considered. The predominant
sources are electric appliances and domestic installations. This is also valid
for dwellings in the vicinity of high-voltage power lines (see below "Is there a link between cancer and low-frequency magnetic fields in the vicinity of high-voltage power lines?".
It is difficult to evaluate the electric field intensity and
the magnetic flux density in a particular case without performing on-site
measurements since the actual exposure at a given place depends on voltage and
current of the power line but also on buildings and plant cover in the
surroundings. The distance from a high-voltage power line in itself is not a
reliable measure for the assessment of the field strength (see also “Static / Low Frequency
Fields Occurrence in
Everyday Life”).
Electric and magnetic fields decrease rapidly with
increasing distance to high-voltage power lines. For example, on average a
magnetic flux density of 1.5 µT was measured at a distance of 20 meters from
the middle of the route of a 380 kV power line. This is far below the limit (of
100 µT) permissible according to the 26th Ordinance on the Implementation of
the Federal Immission Control Law (26. BImSchV). The electric field intensity
values were also below the permissible limits (see " Limit
Values and Precautionary Measures").
The BfS recommendation to restrain from construction under
high-voltage power lines is a precaution to minimise field exposure. Right from
the start this helps to avoid both long-term exposure and annoying perceptions electric shocks (see “Biological and Health Effects of Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields”)
caused by charging effects of conductive objects, which may in some cases occur
even if electric field intensities are below the limit values.
Electric and magnetic fields directly below a high-voltage
power line may possibly be hazardous to people with pacemakers. They might
cause de-synchronization, mainly depending on the type of pacemaker and the
mode of implantation. Since there are many different types of pacemakers,
particular hazards need to be assessed in consultation with the attending
physician.
- Is there a link between cancer and low-frequency magnetic fields in the vicinity of high-voltage power lines?
Potential health risks of low-frequency magnetic fields of
domestic electricity (50 Hz) and electrified transport systems (16 ½ Hz) have
been a controversial issue for years. In the US, the first epidemiological
evidence on a potential connection between cancer and the residential proximity
to high-voltage power lines was published in 1979. Numerous studies have since
tried to illuminate similar issues.
A great number of study results have been assessed by
scientists in many countries. Internationally recognised radiation protection
committees such as the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation
Protection (ICNIRP), the British Health Protection Agency (HPA) or the German
Commission on Radiological Protection (SSK) and the Federal Office for
Radiation Protection (BfS) concluded that there is no proof of a connection
between every day life exposure to magnetic fields and an increased incidence
of cancer in adults. This was recently confirmed by the WHO in the fact sheet
“Electromagnetic fields and public health – exposure to extremely low frequency
fields (see also “WHO Updates Risk Assessment of Low Frequency Fields”).
Several recent epidemiological studies show, however, a
relationship between childhood leukaemia and low-frequency magnetic fields
below limit values. One of these studies was carried out on behalf of BfS (so
called Michaelis-Studie).
The low frequency magnetic fields in the domestic environment of 514 children
with leukaemia were measured. There was a control group of 1.301 healthy
children.
The results of the measurements are in agreement with those
of an extensive investigation previously performed by the BfS. They show that
the fields in dwellings – as measured over a 24-hour period – amount to 0.05
microtesla (µT) on average. Dwellings are referred to as exposed if they
present an average exposure of more than 0.2 µT. However, this group only
consisted of very few participants. High-voltage power lines were responsible
for magnetic field exposures above 0.2µT in only one third of the cases. Other
relevant field sources were, e.g., rising mains and out-dated electric
installations in the houses investigated.
A connection between field intensity and childhood leukaemia can be established for values exceeding 0.4 µT. As for all epidemiological studies a causal relationship is not proven by this statistical correlation. A biological mechanism explaining the development of leukaemia or the facilitation of growth of leukaemia cells by low-frequency magnetic fields could not be detected up to now. The authors of the study state that 1 % of leukaemia cases in children at the most could be explained by an increased exposure to low-frequency magnetic fields if there were in fact a causal relationship (see “Biological and Health Effects of Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields”.
It is not known how exposure to low-frequency magnetic
fields in a very low range of intensity can lead to an increased risk of
leukaemia. Other unknown risk factors for childhood leukaemia might possibly
also play a part. In 2001, after an expert scientific review the International
Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) of the World Health Organization
classified low-frequency magnetic fields as possibly carcinogenic to humans
based on epidemiological studies of childhood leukaemia. WHO reviewed the issue again in 2007 and confirmed the classification.
Although epidemiological studies cannot reveal a causal relationship, the results of these studies demonstrate the necessity of precautionary measures.
- What are the field intensities in the vicinity of transformers?
Transformer stations may contribute to the magnetic field
exposure in dwellings in their immediate vicinity. The height of exposure is
linked to the total electricity volume of such installations. At night the
exposure is usually lower than at peak times.
The magnetic flux densities observed in the immediate
vicinity of low-voltage transformers generally amount to 30 to 100 microtesla
(µT), depending on the current electric power consumption. These field
intensities are reduced to values between 1 and 5 microtesla at a distance of 1
or 2 meters, so that not even a fraction of the limit value for power supply installations is reached. For each individual case, however,
the situation can only be specifically assessed if concrete measurements of the
electric and magnetic fields are available.
No evidence of health risks caused by low-frequency electric and magnetic fields has been found so far. Nevertheless as a precaution, exposure can be minimised e.g., by ensuring that frequently used rooms such as bedrooms are not in the immediate vicinity of such transformer stations and by not putting the bed next to the wall nearest to the transformer station.
- How were limit values determined?
Electric currents in the body are the crucial factors for health effects of low-frequency electric and magnetic fields. If currents above a certain threshold value are induced in the body health hazards may occur (see “Biological
and Health Effects of Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields”).
In order to obviate these health hazards current
density in the body (reported as milliampere per square meter (mA/m2)) is
restricted. The International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection
(ICNIRP) and the German Commission on Radiological Protection (SSK) recommend a
basic limit for the field induced current density of 2 mA/m2. This basic limit
was defined according to the available scientific knowledge on established
health effects of those fields.
Since current densities in the body are difficult to
determine easily measurable physical quantities were derived from the basic
limit: the electric field strength (reported as kilovolt per meter (kV/m)) and
the magnetic flux density (reported as microtesla (µT)). Limit values for the
electric field strength and the magnetic flux density are defined in the 26th Ordinance
on the Implementation of the Federal Pollution Control Act (26. BImSchV). The
limit value for the electric field strength at a frequency of 50 Hz (electrical
power supply) is 5 kV/m and at a frequency of 16.7 Hz (electrified traffic
systems) it is 10 kV/m. The magnetic flux density is restricted to 100 µT at 50
Hz and to 300 µT at 16.7 Hz. As long as these limit values are complied with, a
compliance with the basic limit value is also guaranteed.