What is the basis of precautionary measures?
The effects of electromagnetic fields on human beings are
well known today. This statement is valid both for the low-frequency electric
and magnetic fields of power supply systems and for the high-frequency
electromagnetic fields used in mobile telecommunication systems.
The documented health effects of such fields only occur if
certain field intensities are exceeded. The legal limits as set out in the 26th
Ordinance on the Implementation of the Federal Emission Protection Law
(Ordinance on electromagnetic fields – 26th; BImSchV; in force since January
1st, 1997) for fixed and commercially applied low-frequency (e.g. high-voltage
power lines) as well as high-frequency installations (e.g. mobile phone base
stations) prevent such health effects.
It is impossible to prove that health related risks do not exist at all by scientific means. However, science can characterize the likelihood of adverse health effects. It is always possible that there are risks which up to now are not fully apprehended by scientists.
Moreover there still exist uncertainties regarding risk evaluation for high-frequency electromagnetic fields that could not be completely resolved by the German Mobile Telecommunication Research Programme. Regarding possible health risks when using mobile phones for more than 10 years data are not sufficient for a final conclusion. Mobile telecommunication is an emerging technology and brain tumours have a long latency. The number of persons using their mobile phone for more than ten years is too low to provide statistically reliable data. The question if children are more exposed or more sensitive to high frequency electromagnetic fields than adults remains open. Within the German Mobile Telecommunication Research Programme numerous conceivable study designs were pursued. However, current data are not sufficient to provide conclusive answers to the question on possible health risks for children and adolescents.
For low-frequency magnetic fields there is consistent
evidence for a possible health risk from epidemiological studies (see “Biological
and Health Effects of Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields”). This empiric information has led the WHO to categorize low frequency magnetic fields as possible carcinogenic for humans.
To deal with such uncertainties, prevention from known risks through limits has to be complemented by precautionary measures.
For the Federal Office for Radiation Protection (BfS)
precautionary measures are important and appropriate in view of the existing
scientific uncertainties regarding the potential risks of electric, magnetic,
and electromagnetic fields. An important aspect of precaution is to reduce
exposure of the public to electromagnetic fields both by lowering the field
intensity and by reducing the duration of an exposure. Other precautionary
measures are to intensify research in order to reduce scientific
uncertainties and to broaden the current state of knowledge as well as
providing information and education to the public. These two tasks are
performed by BfS.
What precautionary measures can people take themselves?
Everyone has the chance to minimise the effects of low-frequency electric and magnetic fields as well as of high-frequency electromagnetic fields individually.
– Keep a distance
The intensities of both low-frequency and high-frequency
fields decrease strongly in most cases when the distance to the field source is
increased. So keeping a further distance is a simple method which often helps
to clearly reduce exposure. Examples for specific measures are: do not place
mains-operated clock radios close to your bed-head; install the baby monitor at
least one metre away from your baby, place the power supply unit as far away
from your baby as possible.
– Reduce the duration of exposures – switch off standby sources.
A lot of devices are not switched off or left on standby even when they are not used. This behaviour does not only lead to
wasting energy but it also leads to produce magnetic fields that could
be avoided as a precautionary measure.
- Use radiation reduced appliances.
For some appliances there is information concerning EMF
emission available from the manufacturer or on the internet; for cell phones
and cordless telephones (DECT phones) for example at http://www.bfs.de/en/elektro.
For cell phones and baby monitors an environmental label (Blauer Engel) exists.
For cell phones, however, it is not really used by the manufacturers. On the basis of information on the SAR value available at the internet users can choose a mobile phone with low radiation levels.